The Toyota 86, along with its Subaru BRZ twin, has carved a unique niche in the automotive world: an affordable, rear-wheel-drive sports car focused on driving enjoyment above all else. But are these cars actually good? They certainly aren't the fastest, nor are they the most luxurious, but their appeal lies in a pure, unfiltered driving experience that's becoming increasingly rare. Let's dive into what makes the 86 (and its BRZ sibling, as much of this applies to both) tick, and what experts and owners have to say.
What’s the Big Deal About the Toyota 86 Anyway?
The Toyota 86 (originally known as the Scion FR-S in some markets) debuted to widespread acclaim for its back-to-basics approach to sports car design. In a world of increasingly complex and technology-laden vehicles, the 86 offered a refreshing return to simpler times.
- Rear-wheel drive: This is the heart and soul of the 86's appeal. Delivering power to the rear wheels allows for playful handling characteristics and a more engaging driving experience.
- Lightweight design: Shedding unnecessary weight was a key priority. This contributes to the car's agility and responsiveness.
- Affordable price point: The 86 aimed to be accessible to a wider range of buyers, making the joy of owning a sports car a more realistic possibility.
- Focus on handling: Instead of chasing outright horsepower, the 86 prioritized precise steering, a well-balanced chassis, and a communicative suspension.
These elements combined to create a car that was fun to drive, even at relatively low speeds. It wasn't about breaking land speed records; it was about the feeling of connection between driver and machine.
The Good Stuff: What the Experts Rave About
Experts consistently praise the Toyota 86 for its driving dynamics. Here’s a breakdown of the key strengths:
- Exceptional Handling: This is the 86's defining characteristic. The car feels incredibly nimble and responsive, making it a joy to throw into corners. The steering is precise and well-weighted, providing excellent feedback to the driver. Many reviewers describe it as "telepathic" or "intuitive."
- Balanced Chassis: The 86 boasts a near-perfect weight distribution (around 53/47 front/rear), which contributes to its neutral handling. This means the car is less prone to understeer or oversteer, making it predictable and confidence-inspiring.
- Fun Factor: Simply put, the 86 is a blast to drive. Its playful nature encourages drivers to explore its limits and hone their skills. It's a car that rewards smooth inputs and precise control. Even at legal speeds, it offers a sense of excitement and engagement that's often missing in modern cars.
- Affordability: Compared to other sports cars, the 86 is relatively affordable, making it an accessible entry point into the world of rear-wheel-drive performance. This makes it an attractive option for enthusiasts on a budget.
- Modifiability: The 86 has a thriving aftermarket scene, with a wide range of parts available to customize and improve its performance. From suspension upgrades to engine modifications, the possibilities are endless. This allows owners to tailor the car to their specific needs and preferences.
Key Insight: Experts consistently highlight the 86's handling prowess and fun-to-drive factor as its defining characteristics.
The Not-So-Good Stuff: Addressing the Criticisms
While the Toyota 86 has many strengths, it's not without its flaws. Here are some of the common criticisms:
- Lack of Power: The 2.0-liter flat-four engine, while reliable, has been criticized for its lack of low-end torque. This can make the car feel sluggish at times, especially when accelerating from a standstill or climbing hills. This "torque dip" around 3,000-4,000 RPM is a well-documented issue.
- Interior Quality: The interior of the 86 is functional but not particularly luxurious. The materials are basic, and the design is somewhat dated. While this isn't a deal-breaker for many enthusiasts, it's an area where the car could be improved.
- Road Noise: The 86 can be quite noisy on the road, especially at highway speeds. This is due to the car's lightweight construction and lack of sound insulation. It can make long journeys tiring.
- Limited Practicality: The rear seats are small and cramped, making them unsuitable for adults. The trunk is also relatively small, limiting the car's practicality for everyday use. It's definitely not a family car.
- Reliability Concerns (Early Models): Some early models (particularly 2013 models) experienced valve spring issues. While this was addressed in later model years, it's something to be aware of when considering a used 86.
Important Note: The lack of power is the most common complaint about the 86. However, many owners argue that the car's handling and overall driving experience more than make up for this deficiency.
What About the Competition? How Does the 86 Stack Up?
The Toyota 86 faces competition from a variety of vehicles, including:
- Mazda MX-5 Miata: The Miata is another lightweight, rear-wheel-drive sports car that's known for its exceptional handling. It's often considered the 86's closest competitor. The Miata is generally considered to have a slightly more refined interior and a more engaging engine note, while the 86 offers a more aggressive driving experience and more room for modification.
- Hyundai Veloster N: The Veloster N is a high-performance hatchback that offers a similar level of driving excitement to the 86. It has a more powerful engine and a more practical interior, but it lacks the rear-wheel-drive purity of the 86.
- Volkswagen GTI: The GTI is a popular hot hatchback that's known for its balanced performance and practicality. It's a more versatile car than the 86, but it doesn't offer the same level of driving engagement.
- Nissan Z (Newer Models): While significantly more expensive, the newer Nissan Z offers a more powerful and refined sports car experience. It's a step up in terms of performance and luxury, but it also comes with a higher price tag.
Comparison Insight: The 86 stands out for its focus on pure driving enjoyment and its rear-wheel-drive configuration, making it a unique offering in its price range.
Owner Reviews: Real-World Experiences
While expert reviews provide valuable insights, it's also important to consider the experiences of actual owners. Here's a summary of what owners typically say about the Toyota 86:
- Love the Handling: Owners consistently rave about the 86's handling. They describe it as being responsive, predictable, and incredibly fun.
- Fun to Drive: The 86 is often praised for its playful nature and its ability to put a smile on the driver's face.
- Great Value: Many owners feel that the 86 offers excellent value for the money, especially considering its performance and driving experience.
- Reliable: The 86 is generally considered to be a reliable car, with few major mechanical issues.
- Enjoyable to Modify: Owners appreciate the 86's modifiability and the ability to customize it to their liking.
- Wish for More Power: The lack of power is a common complaint among owners. Many consider aftermarket modifications to address this issue.
- Practicality Limitations Understood: Owners generally understand the car's limitations in terms of practicality and are willing to accept them in exchange for the driving experience.
Owner Sentiment: The overwhelming majority of 86 owners are highly satisfied with their cars, citing the handling, fun factor, and overall driving experience as the main reasons for their satisfaction.
Is a Used Toyota 86 a Good Buy?
A used Toyota 86 can be a great option, especially for budget-conscious enthusiasts. Here are some things to consider:
- Check for Maintenance Records: Look for a car with a well-documented maintenance history. This will give you confidence that the car has been properly cared for.
- Inspect for Modifications: If the car has been modified, make sure the modifications were done professionally and that they haven't negatively impacted the car's reliability.
- Test Drive Thoroughly: Take the car for a thorough test drive to assess its handling, performance, and overall condition.
- Consider Model Year: Be aware of the valve spring issues that affected some early models (2013). Later model years are generally considered to be more reliable.
- Get a Pre-Purchase Inspection: Before buying a used 86, it's always a good idea to have it inspected by a qualified mechanic.
Used Car Tip: A well-maintained, unmodified 86 from a later model year is generally the safest bet when buying used.
Frequently Asked Questions
- Is the Toyota 86 fast? No, the Toyota 86 is not particularly fast in a straight line. Its focus is on handling and cornering rather than outright speed.
- Is the Toyota 86 reliable? Yes, the Toyota 86 is generally considered to be a reliable car, especially later models.
- Is the Toyota 86 good in the snow? The Toyota 86 is not ideal for driving in snow due to its rear-wheel-drive configuration and low ground clearance. Winter tires are highly recommended if you plan to drive it in snowy conditions.
- Is the Toyota 86 comfortable for long trips? The Toyota 86 is not the most comfortable car for long trips due to its firm suspension and road noise.
- What is the "torque dip" in the Toyota 86? The "torque dip" refers to a noticeable drop in torque output around 3,000-4,000 RPM, which can make the car feel sluggish at times.
Final Verdict: Is the Toyota 86 a Good Car?
The Toyota 86 is a good car for those who prioritize driving enjoyment above all else. Its exceptional handling, balanced chassis, and affordable price make it a unique and compelling option in the sports car market. While it's not without its flaws, its strengths far outweigh its weaknesses for enthusiasts seeking a pure, unfiltered driving experience. If you want a fun, engaging, and affordable sports car, the 86 is definitely worth considering.